The Age's chief gobbler of thoughts more empty than any ping pong ball has today tapped the Parkville Asylum's Brendan Gleeson, professor of urban policy studies and director of the Melbourne Sustainable Society Institute, who thinks it is a terrible idea to build a tunnel connecting the Eastern and Westgate freeways. As you might imagine, anyone who heads an institute with the word "sustainable" in its title would say that, in this instance wrapping his personal disdain for cars and the freedom they confer in the garments of, ahem, economic analysis, purported polling and professorial insight.
What Gleeson doesn't mention, nor did the editor who published his thoughts, is that bottom-line considerations he cites are but waving branches above the rather less apparent tap root of his objections. You will need to survey his output to see where he is coming from, and it is most certainly not Doncaster en route by private vehicle to Werribee, otherwise he would be promoting the tunnel for all his ARC grants and sinecures are worth (a very pretty penny, that).
The thing to understand about Gleeson is that when cars go whizzing by his Malvern Star he thinks not of others' convenience but of class struggle and injustice. Indeed, amongst his grant-funded scribblings, concern for "the disadvantaged" and their alleged lack of personal mobility features prominently:
The problem of transport-related social exclusion has formed the basis for a great deal of transport policy development in the United Kingdom in the past decade. More recently, the problem of transport-mediated social exclusion has been investigated in Australia through notions of forced car ownership...
Unless you are a Fairfax editorial page director, you will get the picture: If we are to have a just and more equitable society, better-off citizens must be forced to get around on bicycles and public transport, which Gaia wants with all heart:
...the east-west link scorns the urgent need to decarbonise our cities in the face of a species emergency, global warming. Other cities and nations will judge us severely for building this smog factory in a time of planetary crisis.Come on, Gina, stop buggarising around. If you're not going to take full charge of Fairfax, then dump your holding. Even a minority interest in this stupid, stupid company demeans your good name and reputation.
One of the interesting things the Greens, Fairfaxistas and other assorted hippies and communists forget is that things called trucks use roads and they are essential for the transport of goods. Dutch-style bicycles with panniers on the front might be cute delivery vehicles for artisan bakeries in North Fitzroy but otherwise are pretty limited. For a happy 56 hours in a good week I live in the very heart of latte-land, a 10 minute walk from Princes Street and the Eastern Highway. One of the biggest reasons I want the bloody tunnel is that it will send the trucks underground and greatly improve the area. The Greens/Fairfaxistas/hippies/communists are either too thick or too intellectually dishonest to mention this.ReplyDelete
If the East-West is anything like the Burnley and Domain tunnels, the trucks will not be able to use it.Delete
You'd think a bike promoter would be partial to the notion of freeways being below ground with cyclists above riding on less congested roads. If only we could be so lucky out in the suburbs.ReplyDelete
Similar Gaia loving motives induced the Bayside councils to propose a daytime truck ban in their various municipalities back in the '80s. The TWU said "Fine. You'll just have to go elsewhere to shop for everything because there will be no more trucks anytime in your areas". A rapid ratepayer induced change of the collective council mind occurred. [reported IQ in single figures]. Perhaps a similar approach to that of the TWU may change the good academic's mind. No more delivery of coffee beans and mung beans.ReplyDelete
Know you're an admirer of Julia Baird's prose.ReplyDelete
I drove a visitor from ecological London around Sydney not long ago utilising the cross-city, harbour and other freeway tunnels (and some big bridges) to whiz all over town a few times. He was green. With envy.ReplyDelete
Just because Gina was naive enough to think she could buy the loyalty of her kids instead of assisting them to develop their self esteem, doesn't mean she isn't smart enough to spot a very obvious legit. tax dodge. Just as a Doctor buys a farm, Gina buys into a seriously failing Fairfax.ReplyDelete